Your arms are not the first to hold me tight
But your arms are the last to hold me right
Darling, we found something, oh so rare
And we're caught between a love and a love affair

How I wish I could turn back the hands of time
If I could only do it over you'd be mine
And my arms would give the watch to keep you there
Oh, we're caught between a love and a love affair

So we'll just slip around and see each other when we can
'Cause you care for your woman and you care for your man
So we just can't find within what we have here
Oh, we're caught between a love and a love affair

Yes, we're caught between a love and a love affair