I can't remember when
We both held hands and skipped together off of the edge
The man in the moon was looking me straight in the eye
And I stared right back as I kissed you goodnight
I ran next to your car as you pulled away
You rolled the window down and told me that you wanted to stay
I hung my head as the bright lights faded to black
And then I looked up, just in time to see you coming back

Don't leave me
Please baby
I don't want to tell you maybe
I don't want to give you away
I just want to hear you say

I love you baby, give it
A chance before you throw it away
C'mon on baby, give it
Ten seconds of your time, girl I pray
You'll see my heart is breaking
I'm trying not to cry from the pain
Come on baby, give it
A chance before you throw it away

I can't remember when you were
The apple of my eye, who I kept hidden inside
The one I kept hidden from the rest of the world
So no one else could see you
And you'd still be my girl

I love you baby, give it
A chance before you throw it away
C'mon on baby, give it
Ten seconds of your time, girl I pray
You'll see my heart is breaking
I'm trying not to cry from the pain
Come on baby, give it
A chance before you throw it away