Why didn't I listen to my heart?
When she had me guessing from the start,
More and more I wonder,
Why do I still want her?
After all the love I gave to you,
All this pain and all because of you

(Chorus)

What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Where am I supposed to go when it's dark outside?
What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Lie to me lie to me,
Lie to me lie to me,
Lie to me lie to me one last time,

Still have those letters from last fall,
And every time the phone rings,
Wish it was your call,
More and more I wonder,
Why do I still want her?
After all the love I gave to you,
All this pain I'm in because of you,
(You, you, you, you, you)

(Chorus)

What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Where am I supposed to go when it's dark outside?
What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Lie to me lie to me,
Lie to me lie to me,
Lie to me lie to me one last time,

Why did you have to hide?
Loved you through all your lies
One thing I know is true
I'll never stop loving you
Lovin' you
So tell me,
What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Where am I supposed to go when it's dark outside?
What am I supposed to do when it's all a lie?
Won't you Lie to me lie to me baby,
Lie to me lie to me baby,(high)
Lie to me baby, one last time