I met Joe through a friend of a friend
Tuesday at my show
That smile that voice
We made plans, I had no choice
Ben on the other hand
Cute as can be, but harder to read
We made plans to meet as well
This could get hectic
But what the hell

I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows
Put 'em together a perfect ten
You'd have Joseph's heart and brains like Ben
I Guess, One of you two's got to go

Oh oh
Na na na na na na
Do do do do do
Na na

Fun till someone gets hurt
I love the attention I hate all the work Slow Down, Keep it all straight
Did I call you his name at the end of our date?
Oh man it's tough but

I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows
Put 'em together a perfect ten
You'd have Joseph's heart and brains like Ben
I Guess

There's a first time for everything
It's the last time that I try this thing
I gotta get myself out of this mess
I guess
I gotta get myself out of this

I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows!
Put 'em together a perfect ten
He'd have Joseph's heart and brains like Ben

I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows
I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows

I Guess, One of you two's got to go
I'm makin' dinner for two and what if the other guy shows
I Guess