You're unfaithful, yet your betrayal is beautiful somehow
Just like your five in the mornings are so romantic
Everything's storybook
It's so cute the way you'd sing along to love songs after dark
In the backseat of the car

I should've known the moment you left the house
After I took you home

You said "Everyone was doing it"

The top shelf display in your bedroom tells the entire story
So tell it one more time
Tuck me in and say "goodnight"

All I'm asking for is too feel butterflies again
Genuine and honest is that too much to ask?