You were a young girl, fresh to the city, always wanted real love, nothing cold and empty,
He stoked the flame in you, and turned a spark to fire,
Never heard when your mama said, loves not the same as desire

When he said, that he really cared about you, then you thought that he really cared about you,
And you dreamed, that he really cared about you, but I know, he could live his life without you

Thief of hearts, what you gonna do when he tears your heart apart, Cause he's wanted dead or alive for the hearts he's scared
And then one day you will find that you can't deny all the things inside for the thief of hearts

No inhibitions and he's got no past, Always in hurry, Should you ever ask
He'll put his spell on you, until you've lost control,
Never heard when your girlfriend said, better leave that man alone

When he said, that he really cared about you, then you thought that he really cared about you,
And you dreamed, that he really cared about you, but I know, he could live his life without you

Thief of hearts, what you gonna do when he tears your heart apart, Cause he's wanted dead or alive for the hearts he's scared
And then one day you will find that you can't deny all the things inside for the thief of hearts

(Yeah baby) You've got feelings, you've got dream so real, take the rose colored glasses of to reveal

Back in the city, where it all began, got a new direction, got a change of plans
He put his heat on you then left you out in the cold, better hear when your daddy says,
Baby girl come back home

When he said, that he really cared about you, then you thought that he really cared about you,
And you dreamed, that he really cared about you, but I know, he could live his life without you

Thief of hearts, what you gonna do when he tears your heart apart, Cause he's wanted dead or alive for the hearts he's scared
And then one day you will find that you can't deny all the things inside for the thief of hearts